diff --git a/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/TrackPageTile.tsx b/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/TrackPageTile.tsx
index 326b05907b..bf4a497254 100644
--- a/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/TrackPageTile.tsx
+++ b/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/TrackPageTile.tsx
@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ export interface TrackPageTileProps {
   onSelect: (
     fileId: FileId,
     pageId: string,
-    modifiers: { shift: boolean; toggle: boolean },
+    modifiers: { shift: boolean },
   ) => void;
   onRotate: (pageIds: string[], delta: number) => void;
   onDelete: (pageIds: string[]) => void;
@@ -81,10 +81,7 @@ function TrackPageTileImpl({
 
   const handleClick = useCallback(
     (event: React.MouseEvent) => {
-      onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, {
-        shift: event.shiftKey,
-        toggle: event.metaKey || event.ctrlKey,
-      });
+      onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, { shift: event.shiftKey });
     },
     [onSelect, trackFileId, page.id],
   );
@@ -120,7 +117,7 @@ function TrackPageTileImpl({
       onKeyDown={(event) => {
         if (event.key === "Enter" || event.key === " ") {
           event.preventDefault();
-          onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, { shift: false, toggle: true });
+          onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, { shift: false });
         }
       }}
     >
@@ -130,9 +127,7 @@ function TrackPageTileImpl({
           aria-label={t("pageTracks.selectPage", "Select page {{number}}", {
             number: position,
           })}
-          onChange={() =>
-            onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, { shift: false, toggle: true })
-          }
+          onChange={() => onSelect(trackFileId, page.id, { shift: false })}
         />
       </div>
 
diff --git a/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/hooks/useTrackSelection.ts b/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/hooks/useTrackSelection.ts
index 61fede8af8..bfa692b6cc 100644
--- a/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/hooks/useTrackSelection.ts
+++ b/frontend/editor/src/core/components/pageTracks/hooks/useTrackSelection.ts
@@ -3,8 +3,8 @@ import { FileId } from "@app/types/file";
 import { TrackWorkspace, allPages } from "@app/components/pageTracks/types";
 
 export interface PageClickModifiers {
+  /** Extend the selection from the last clicked page in the same track. */
   shift: boolean;
-  toggle: boolean;
 }
 
 export interface TrackSelectionHook {
@@ -57,6 +57,12 @@ export function useTrackSelection(
     }
   }, [livePageIds]);
 
+  /**
+   * A click toggles the page in or out of the selection, so pages accumulate
+   * without a modifier: picking a set to rotate or move is the whole job here,
+   * and replace-on-click would make anything past the first page a fight.
+   * Shift extends from the last clicked page instead.
+   */
   const selectPage = useCallback(
     (fileId: FileId, pageId: string, modifiers: PageClickModifiers) => {
       const trackPages = workspaceRef.current.tracks[fileId]?.pages ?? [];
@@ -75,25 +81,18 @@ export function useTrackSelection(
             range.forEach((id) => next.add(id));
             return next;
           });
+          // Anchor stays put so repeated shift-clicks re-extend from it.
           return;
         }
       }
 
       anchorRef.current = { fileId, pageId };
-
-      if (modifiers.toggle) {
-        setSelectedIds((prev) => {
-          const next = new Set(prev);
-          if (next.has(pageId)) next.delete(pageId);
-          else next.add(pageId);
-          return next;
-        });
-        return;
-      }
-
-      setSelectedIds((prev) =>
-        prev.size === 1 && prev.has(pageId) ? new Set() : new Set([pageId]),
-      );
+      setSelectedIds((prev) => {
+        const next = new Set(prev);
+        if (next.has(pageId)) next.delete(pageId);
+        else next.add(pageId);
+        return next;
+      });
     },
     [],
   );
diff --git a/frontend/editor/src/core/tests/stubbed/page-tracks.spec.ts b/frontend/editor/src/core/tests/stubbed/page-tracks.spec.ts
index e4315d900c..884b9d378b 100644
--- a/frontend/editor/src/core/tests/stubbed/page-tracks.spec.ts
+++ b/frontend/editor/src/core/tests/stubbed/page-tracks.spec.ts
@@ -311,4 +311,53 @@ test.describe("Page Editor tracks", () => {
     await page.mouse.up();
     expect(await readRotations(rotated, 4)).toEqual([0, 90, 180, 270]);
   });
+
+  test("clicking pages accumulates the selection instead of replacing it", async ({
+    page,
+  }) => {
+    await openPageEditor(page);
+    const rotated = track(page, "rotated-pages.pdf");
+    const tiles = rotated.locator("[data-page-id]");
+    await expect(tiles).toHaveCount(4, { timeout: 30_000 });
+    const selected = rotated.locator('[data-page-id][data-selected="true"]');
+
+    await tiles.nth(0).click();
+    await expect(selected).toHaveCount(1);
+
+    // The second click must ADD, not move the selection onto page 2.
+    await tiles.nth(1).click();
+    await expect(selected).toHaveCount(2);
+
+    // Clicking a selected page takes it back out again.
+    await tiles.nth(1).click();
+    await expect(selected).toHaveCount(1);
+    await expect(tiles.nth(0)).toHaveAttribute("data-selected", "true");
+
+    // Shift extends from the last clicked page across the whole run.
+    await tiles.nth(3).click({ modifiers: ["Shift"] });
+    await expect(selected).toHaveCount(4);
+
+    // A selection spanning tracks is allowed too.
+    const sample = track(page, "sample.pdf");
+    await sample.locator("[data-page-id]").first().click();
+    await expect(
+      page.locator('[data-page-id][data-selected="true"]'),
+    ).toHaveCount(5);
+  });
+
+  test("a bar action applies to every page the clicks accumulated", async ({
+    page,
+  }) => {
+    await openPageEditor(page);
+    const rotated = track(page, "rotated-pages.pdf");
+    const tiles = rotated.locator("[data-page-id]");
+    expect(await readRotations(rotated, 4)).toEqual([0, 90, 270, 180]);
+
+    await tiles.nth(0).click();
+    await tiles.nth(2).click();
+    await page.getByRole("button", { name: "Rotate right" }).first().click();
+
+    // Only the two clicked pages turn; the ones in between are untouched.
+    expect(await readRotations(rotated, 4)).toEqual([90, 90, 0, 180]);
+  });
 });